The Black Cat AnalogyPhilosophy is like being in a dark room and looking for a black / Funny pictures

auto 
The Black Cat AnalogyPhilosophy is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat.Metaphysics is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat that isn't there.Theology is like being in a dark room and looking for a black catthat isn't there k, i/ and shouting "I found it!"Science s
Details
The Black Cat Analogy Philosophy is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat. Metaphysics is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat that isn't there. Theology is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat that isn't there k, i/ and shouting "I found it!" Science ¡s like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat using a flashlight.
auto
Expand
Comments 4431.03.201000:00link4.6
...And scientistic hubris, like all forms of hubris, is obnoxious.
Paul Keyes Paul Keyes28.06.201323:50responselink 0.0
not all scientists are arrogant, but i can't say that i disagree with you
DeadWhale DeadWhale19.07.201322:58responselink 0.0
Well, .......no.

Theology is like looking for a black cat in a dark room and developing the strength of faith to keep looking when others tell you it isn't there - despite their utter lack of evidence to support this assertion.
Brother John Brother John19.07.201320:07responselink 0.0
you sound like religious man, you know.
DeadWhale DeadWhale19.07.201323:05responselink 0.0
So what?
Brother John Brother John19.07.201323:35responselink 0.0
That would be an *honest* theologian. The other kind - which is most of them - claim to have found it, and then scream "oppression!" when anyone challenges them to produce so much as a shred of fur.
thaddaeusv thaddaeusv05.09.201321:11responselink 0.0
There is a slightly more honest kind who will claim to have found the cat but, upon being challenged, will admit that they haven't *really* found it, they were just saying that to encourage themselves. Those kind are actually worth talking to.

Also, claiming that the cat isn't there is not, properly speaking, an assertion. It is a statement of the null hypothesis. The burden of proof is on the person asserting that something exists, not on the person questioning its existence. In the absence of such proof, the logical conclusion is for non-existence.
thaddaeusv thaddaeusv05.09.201321:17responselink 0.0
Theology is like a pretentious hipster in a darkroom telling you there is a black cat, but you've probably never seen it before. Despite their utter lack of evidence.

Enlightenment is like being in a darkroom and waiting for the black cat to come to you or not and not letting the result affect the way you live. Besides, no cat is going to willingly go to the idiot stumbling in the dark looking for it.
asdkfaasdkfa19.07.201322:12responselink 0.0
only if that idiot hasn't got cat's food with him :D
DeadWhale DeadWhale19.07.201322:59responselink 0.0
Enlightenment is actually leaving the other guy alone. And if you're enlightened, why sit around waiting for the cat - your words - when you know it won't come to you? If it's important to you, you seek out the cat. If it's not, you don't. Simple.
Brother John Brother John19.07.201323:38responselink 0.0
and what if you don't need that cat? you are enlightened and clearly understand that the cat is not what you need, but there is nothing else to look for in the room?
Fluffy Fluffy20.07.201300:02responselink 0.0
Art is imagining a black cat might exist and where one might look for it.
Then... everyone else just says, "cool, let's do that"
onecae onecae20.07.201304:08responselink 0.0
not hubris, just the facts, just think; with all the VERY different beliefs and gods that humans have imagined and worsheped in the world the only rational answer is that they are ALL wrong and there aint no gods. of any sort!!!!
tesmith47 tesmith4720.07.201310:01responselink 0.0
I'd think science would be not assuming there is a cat unless you see, hear, smell, feel or taste said kitty, or any other evidence (e.g., allergic reaction).
Mark Holm Mark Holm20.07.201313:18responselink 0.0
Agnosticism is asking how do I know that a black cat exists. Faith is addiction to authority.
rick0824 rick082420.07.201318:10responselink 0.0
it's easy to be an agnostiс :) does a black cat exist? -I don't know, the world is unknowable :)
Fluffy Fluffy21.07.201310:33responselink 0.0
I don't think it is easy to be agnostic. Most of us are raised from birth to accept the reality of a black cat and unlike Santa Clause, this belief continues into adulthood.
rick0824 rick082421.07.201314:57responselink 0.0
can you draw any example of 'black cat continuing into adulthood'? what do you mean? God?
Fluffy Fluffy22.07.201315:09responselink 0.0
You can say "god" if you want. That's one of the 2-bit words that is repeated so endlessly that it takes on a reality of it's own. What is the referent for the word "god"? The word is not the thing. If you ask 100 people what "god" is you get 100 attributes. Therefore it is meaningless.
rick0824 rick082422.07.201316:23responselink 0.0
maybe I just didn't get you right, but if these word has a meaning for every person (even if the meanings are all different) how can it be meaningful? I think it's just subjective, but does posses some kind of meaming.
Fluffy Fluffy22.07.201316:59responselink 0.0
I think you meant "how can it be meaningless"? Not meaningful. Words are like money. If you have say $100 in American currency and try and spend it in say Russia, you have a problem. In order for the currency to have value both parties to a transaction must have agreement that the currency has the same meaning + value.
Too many people fail to challenge the words being exchanged and assume they have the same values to both people.
rick0824 rick082422.07.201317:31responselink 0.0
you right, I meant meaningless. but here we're talking about the differences between countries, between cultures, right? I don't tnink money is a good example, cause we all know that there exist currency rates. DOn't think that I'm not stubborn, I respect you're opinion, just an interesting theme to talk about:) and you sound sophisticated :)
Fluffy Fluffy23.07.201322:15responselink 0.0
I think money is a good analogy because while it's difference are between cultures you can have the same problem between just 2 people having a conversation. I am a student of semantics + linguistics.
If subjective words have totally different meaning or images between people they are not truly communicating. Don't get me wrong, I respect your opinion too :)
rick0824 rick082424.07.201300:18responselink 0.0
you right, I meant meaningless. but here we're talking about the differences between countries, between cultures, right? I don't tnink money is a good example, cause we all know that there exist currency rates. DOn't think that I'm not stubborn, I respect you're opinion, just an interesting theme to talk about:) and you sound sophisticated :)
Fluffy Fluffy22.07.201318:25responselink 0.0
your opinion*
Fluffy Fluffy22.07.201318:26responselink 0.0
Theology, I think, is about believing th cat is there. And a believe is not a religion per se, but neither is theology. It's a study of believe.
So phylosophy is bout exploring all the possibilities of believing, metphysics about believing the unbelieveble, theology about just believing and science is the only physical search for what there is to believe. And to ever wich effect, we are all equally blind untill we start believing what ever group we do not belong to.
Deb* Deb*23.07.201316:37responselink 0.1
and all these sciences are connected at one point for sure: they ponder over something that you CANNOT see, so I think that they are sooo subjective (i mean metaphysics and theology). 'Theology is about just beleiving, ok I agree but every person believes in different things, so can we call it a science?
Fluffy Fluffy23.07.201322:18responselink 0.0
All four pursuits are an expression of curiosity about the nature of the dark room. And all four have similar ways to describe it and its contents - including the cat - but they all use different metaphors to do so that are hard for proponents of the other groups to accept. Each can be helpful to the others, but dogma restricts their ability to come together and learn. Someday a more advanced species than us will arise and will have the capacity to peer deeper into reality using a combination of philosophy (which includes metaphysics and theology) and science. We are clearly not highly evolved enough to do so, and most of the comments here reflect that.
psterud psterud23.07.201322:26responselink 0.0
theology is the pursuit of an everyday experience that is evident to only the mind that allows vision into the parallel universe, dark matter, dark energy that a being in a 4 dimensional existence cannot fathom without pursuit of that 96% of the unknown.
soferdig soferdig24.07.201310:31responselink 0.0
I still thanks that the more we learn aout universe, the more we fdiscover things we cannot axplain, so that makes a lot of people beleive that god really exists and gives theology a right for a full-fledged place on our lifes
Fluffy Fluffy24.07.201314:49responselink 0.0
Quantum physics: at the same time, the black cat is likely to be there and it's likely it isn't. tomkawal
Tomasz Kawała Tomasz Kawała26.07.201301:22responselink 0.0
Theology - discussing the beliefs about black cat basing on the statements revealed.
Science - confronting the assumptions about black cat with the reality of its existence is fun!
Philosophy - the cat and the black definition, discuss the possibility of black cat perception.
Tomasz Kawała Tomasz Kawała26.07.201301:41responselink 0.0
and I can add that philosophy also tries to prove if it's there anyting else black and anything else 'cat' in the wrold and how these notions are connected to each other
Fluffy Fluffy27.07.201311:06responselink 0.0
I was in the dark room, seeking nothing, denying it was there anyway, when the cat pulled me out into the light, pulled off the blinders I didn't even realise I had on and revealed itself to be a lion.
Joyunspeakable Joyunspeakable28.07.201319:33responselink 0.0
the cat showed you the light and the true meaning of life! Blessed be, THE CAT!
Fluffy Fluffy04.08.201317:04responselink 0.0
Science is all living in a dark room and saying black cats do not exist because there's not one in the room (even looking with the flash light)
trujiji trujiji01.08.201320:44responselink 0.0
the majority of people believe in things they cannot see (like god). but on the other hand, people do believe that there is oxygen around us all the time, though they cannot see it either. seriously, I think that these scientific/religious arguments don't lead us anywhere, it's stupid to make an adult change his or her views. Hah, a lot of still believe that 9/11 was a terrorism, so...
Shubudoyka Shubudoyka04.08.201317:10responselink 0.0
Ah yes, more of this "my way of thinking is superior to yours," bullshit, clearly written by someone with only the vaguest surface-level understanding of the topics they lambast.

Gotta love how Militant Atheism is the fastest growing RELIGION in the world.


"Anyone who thinks differently than me is stupid / wrong / infidel / going to hell" -- sound like any other group you know?


Have fun being amused by your own arrogant stupidity.
blah1234 blah123427.09.201305:18responselink 0.0
theology is like being in a dark room, while the cat who created the room exists outside of it, while leaving traces of it having been there.
mil43314 mil4331416.10.201300:23responselink 0.0
is no one else concerned that there is a black cat out there somewhere that is able to use a flashlight?
Jon Miller Jon Miller04.11.201303:01responselink 0.0
Has anyone suggested that it is easy for a non-scientist to find out whether there is a cat using a teaspoon of cat food?
ralphsu21 ralphsu2118.02.201406:17responselink 0.0
Those fields require different senses to be used besides affirmed vision, hence the mention of dark room. Feeling, intuition, logic, motion, critical thinking are used. We don't understand how those processes work so we can't "prove" anything.
Tyler Balkman Tyler Balkman22.06.201409:11responselink 0.0
There is no black cat.
There is no dark room.
All.
Is.
Illusion.
-Buddhism
James Talbot James Talbot23.06.201408:46responselink 0.0
Absence of evidence is NOT evidence of absence. The idea that "the burden of proof is on those claiming there IS a cat" springs from the dogma of scientific thought and logic. Insisting this is every bit as much an article of faith as insisting that the Bible is the sole arbiter of reality.
goldenskyhook goldenskyhook23.06.201421:00responselink 0.0

Picture: from file   from URL
Related tags

Similar posts